Let me first begin by saying I feel people
should stand up for what they believe in.
However, this case is a perfect example of how standing up can be done
in a horribly wrong way. Kyle Brooks could
have expressed his views/concerns by many means, yet he chose the path of
cowardice, showing no concern for those he harmed (and is still harming) in
order to benefit himself.
First, let’s cover what Kyle’s
actions entailed. While listening to a
guest speaker (Biddle), Kyle was offended by some of Biddle’s comments. Therefore, he secretly pulled out his phone
and began recording Biddle’s presentation.
Later the same day, Kyle then posted the video to multiple sources, and
the story spread like wild fire, eventually gaining national attention with
Kyle getting an interview on Fox News.
When Kyle began to get offended by
the speaker, there were multiple ways he could have handled the situation. He could have raised his hand and countered
the speaker during the presentation (if this was allowed). If this was not an option, he could have
talked to the speaker or the professor after class. He could have expressed his views on the blog
which is specifically created for his class to discuss the topics covered in
class. Or, if he simply couldn’t handle
a viewpoint that was different than his own, he could have left the class, an
action which would have shown his irritation in a powerful yet peaceful way
(even if it is rather dogmatic).
Instead of this, Kyle took the low
road. Is Kyle proud of what he did? Is he proud that performed an illegal action
(videotaping the speaker)? Is he proud that he was too much of a coward to
confront the professor or Biddle face-to-face, and instead went behind their
backs to a news station which skewed the words of Biddle, allowed him to insult
his professor without her being able to defend herself, and basically insulted
the entire campus? Is all of this
negativity worth Kyle getting media attention and a potential future career
with groups of people as narrow minded as he is? Throughout the remainder of Kyle’s life he is
going to encounter people who are different; is this how he is going to react
every time? Is he going to attempt to
get them negative national coverage all for his own personal gain? Is Kyle incapable of hearing views that go
against his own? If so, he will never be
able to function in this society. With
all the grief that Biddle and the professor have been getting, Kyle deserves
every ounce of anger thrown at him.
Were Biddle’s comments
controversial? Yes. Should Biddle consider changing his
presentation so it is less offensive?
Arguably yes. Was Biddle’s presentation
horrible enough to justify Kyle’s actions?
NO! I watched a good chunk of the
presentation, and while I might not have agreed with what Biddle said, I was
never gasping in horror. I also feel the
professor made no mistakes, except being a Democrat with Kyle Brooks in her
class. She tried to show a viewpoint,
believing her students were mature enough to handle it, and unfortunately, Kyle
was not. If this campus truly is as
Democrat favored as Kyle says it is (many feel the opposite way), and if he feels
so out of place, then he should just leave and try another campus. If Kyle has any dignity whatsoever, he will
apologize to both Biddle and his professor, both privately and publically. But until that happens, I feel Kyle is an
immoral coward who is not fit to be in any adult institution.
No comments:
Post a Comment